US Constitution, The First Amendment Discussions

From the Book: The U.S. Constitution; Explained Clause by Clause for Every American today!

Shobeir Seddington
2 min readJan 3, 2021

The following answers the question: Is the United States of America a democracy or a republic based on the first amendment? :)

One argued, “Under a democracy, whose great end is to form a code of laws congenial with the public sentiment, the popular opinion ought to be collected and attended to. Our Government is derived from the people, of consequence, the people have a right to consult for the common good.”

A congressman on the other side responded: “Representation is the principle of our Government; the people ought to have confidence in the honor and integrity of those they send forward to transact their business.”

Back and forth they went and in the end, they decided by a vote of 41 to 10 not to include the right of the people to instruct their representatives.

The United States would be a republic and not a democracy.

Last year, I read a great book on the late Ruth Badar Ginsberg. RBG’s revere for the constitution was infectious and the book sparked new regard and appreciation for the U.S. Constitution in me. Accidentally, while walking around SFO’s bookstore, I stumbled upon a nice little book that piqued my interest and I am so happy that I listened to my wife and bought it!

The U.S. Constitution; Explained Clause by Clause for Every American Today Annotated by Ray Raphael (Buy on Amazon) ($6.99 on Kindle)

To my surprise, this made an excellent read for the flight. I love how Ray Raphael concisely brings relevant conversations and facts from history while connecting them to current affairs and discussions. I believe everyone can benefit from reading it, simply to understand the misuse of the Bill of Rights or amendments in today’s news and media.

The first book finished in 2021.
Highly Recommended 4.5/5.

--

--

Shobeir Seddington

Quantum Roots, Data Dreams: A Journey Through Science, Life, and the Art of Possibilities. "Opinions expressed are solely my own."